Susan catsits for a neighbor when she realizes someone has broken in. At a neighborhood watch meeting, Susan gives a screwdriver she found at the scene of the crime to a handsome cop. He asks her out and at first she says she's not available. But then he charms her into agreeing. She decides to ask Mike's permission and he tells her he doesn't have an opinion. Frustrated, she worries that Mike is a "Karl" in disguise, another jerk like her ex-husband.