Three's a Crowd
In the middle of a make-out session Mike tells Susan he loves her. When she doesn't respond right away, he thinks she still has feelings for her ex, Karl. Edie lets it slip that she made out with Karl while he was still married. Midway through her rendition of "New York, New York" at a karaoke party, Susan launches into an angry tirade against Karl and his infidelity. Susan's little town blues…are melting away… Susan later realizes that she really doesn't have any feelings for Karl anymore and giddily runs over to Mike's to tell him that she loves him. But she's not the only one anxious to chat with Mike. The police are already there asking about Martha Huber.