It’s Christmas Day in Port Charles. Patrick has finally made his decision between Robin and Sabrina. Which worthy lady will wake up elated to find Patrick by her side? Unfortunately, the other will start her Christmas Day devastated that Patrick called it quits with her, but she'll find comfort for her broken heart in a man from her past. Patrick gives an especially poignant gift to the woman he wants to spend the rest of his life with. Sabrina makes a startling discovery – a wounded Carlos is hiding out at her apartment after the shootout, begging her to not turn him in to the cops. Dante heads down to PCPD seeking the truth about what really went down at the warehouse. How did Max end up getting shot? Sonny covers for Morgan (the real shooter) and sticks with his story that his gun went off by accident. Diane and Milo hold vigil at Max's bedside. Morgan is overcome with guilt over shooting Max at the warehouse. Nikolas and a guilt-ridden Britt visit Lulu for the holidays. Uneasy as she sees Lulu next to Ben, Britt's guilt is killing her, and she makes a heartfelt gesture to Lulu about trying to have a baby yet another shot. Will Lulu ever learn the reason why she feels connected to baby Ben? Ava toys with AJ's emotions causing AJ to once again hit the bottle.