A female hiker is found badly injured in a ravine. Meredith realizes that she wasn't hiking at all. She was running from someone. The young girl's x-rays reveal years of wounds that have gone untreated. Teddy's seen injuries like this before in people who were tortured. Meredith asks the girl for her name. She says "he" called her Susan, but she believes her name is actually Holly, as in Holly Wheeler. She's someone who was kidnapped when she was six years old. Holly has been missing for many years. Until now.
Owen feels like he's in over his head with the all the attention that the Holly Wheeler case is drawing to the hospital. Richard assures him he'll be just fine. Owen's first task is dealing with the press. He must also try to comfort the girl's father who is upset because someone snapped a photo of Holly in the hallway. Cristina sees how difficult all this is for Owen. She lets him know that he's doing the best he can.
Holly forms a bond with Meredith. She looks to her for assurances on everything. This includes whether or not she should let her parents hug her. Holly is still traumatized by all that she's been through. Speaking of being traumatized, Bailey is paralyzed with fear once she realizes Tuck is missing from the daycare center. Thankfully, her son is just fine. He just had to be taken to the nurse. Bailey is relieved after briefly experiencing the feelings that come with every parent's worst nightmare.