1. He's Hunting for Henry
Wait, what? Somehow, hundreds of years ago when Baelfire wound up being found by the Lost Ones, we see that Peter Pan has his creepy minions searching for a particular boy and it's Henry! I have no idea what that means, I just know that it's freaking me out!
2. The Lost Ones
Speaking of Peter Pan's goon squad, is it me or do these guys look significantly less pleasant than I remember hearing about. Even Captain Hook was worried about crossing them.
3. The Whole Kidnapping Thing
Again, we're used to hearing the story of how Peter Pan's mischievious shadow takes the Darling children on a fun adventure and, uh, this is different. This is more like creepy nightmare shadow breaking into the room trying to steal children away forever. Yikes!
4. Peter Won't Let You Leave
It was creepy enough when Wendy Darling came back in the morning, shaken by what she saw, but it got REALLY creepy when she told Baelfire that Peter won't let anyone who touches Neverland's soil leave. EVER.
5. Rumplestiltskin Admits He's Scared of Him
If you weren't creeped out before, this should do it. When THE DARK ONE says this guy is someone "we all should fear," that's how you know you're dealing with one truly creepy guy.
So does Peter Pan have you creeped out, too? Share your theories about what he's really going to be like in the comments!