Taking a rare night shift, Emma spotted Graham sneaking out of Regina's window and was shocked. She tried to avoid him, but when he kissed her, his memories of life as The Huntsman in Fairy Tale Land began to come flooding back. Despite being hurt by him being with Regina, Emma helped Graham break into the Mayor's family crypt looking for his heart. When Regina caught them there together, she and Emma finally came to blows. The Sheriff broke up the fight, but when he also broke up with Regina, she was enraged that he would choose Emma over her. As Emma and Graham shared their first real kiss, and his memories of Fairy Tale Land returned fully, Regina crushed his stolen heart, killing him!